With economic recovery still distant, business marketers look to 2010 and wonder what’s in store. How do you do more with less resources is a common question I hear from CMOs, VPs of Marketing, and marketing directors with whom I speak daily. Modern marketing can not scale effectively without automation. And while it is not the cure-all to every problem, automation can help tune the marketing mix, scale online and social efforts, deliver better returns on campaign investment, put more qualified leads in front of sales, and create a direct, visible connection between marketing programs and business impact.
When it comes to marketing automation, B2B marketers need technology specifically geared around capturing demand and qualifying it for sales attention. However, picking the solution best positioned to deliver on lead management automation’s promise of stronger pipelines and more predictable marketing results frustrates B2B marketers at large and small firms alike. Frankly, the market is awash with competitors and claims. The 800-pound gorillas lack track records with current feature sets and many of the smaller players, with the exception of Eloqua, have yet to top the $25 million dollar mark in annual revenues.
To help B2B marketers sort out the space, I am soon publishing a report reviewing the B2B lead management automation market. While the report mentions almost 50 different companies, I lined up 18 of the most promising technology providers and compared capabilities. Included specifically in the report are Aprimo, Eloqua, eTrigue, Genius.com, HubSpot, LeadLife Solutions, Leads360, Loopfuse, Manticore Technology, Market2Lead, MarketBright, Marketo, Neolane, Pardot, salesforce.com, Silverpop, Sitecore, and Unica. I also talk a lot about where the market is going and what holds it back.
During the next few weeks, I plan to use this blog to share some of the findings and ideas that hit the cutting room floor. And to open a dialog with you, the suppliers, and anyone else who wants to talk about how to make this technology work and how to keep the market thriving. I know as soon as I publish this post, I know I’ll start to get comments about why this list and why were others left off. The answer is simple: this is a start.
The report looks at overall trends and issues in the evolving lead management automation space; it does not provide an in-depth comparison of all the possible providers. To rate inclusion in the “Harvey ball” comparison table, I required vendors to demonstrate market tenure and penetration. We looked at firms with over 50 customer accounts by August 1, 2009, more than five competitive mentions (in a recent survey), products successfully sold for 12 months or longer, and product offerings that met the majority of our criteria, which includes a full complement of lead scoring/qualification, nurturing, routing/sales force enablement, and reporting capability. If a firm didn’t meet all these criteria, they were left out of what I am sure will become “infamous” Figure 5. All vendors reviewed received an advanced copy of the report and the opportunity to comment. Which some did. Extensively.
As the publication date draws nearer (in the next couple of weeks or so) I’ll blog more about the results. In the meantime, feel free to weigh in and let me know what you think of the list and the market. If you are considering a lead management automation investment, who would you include and why? While the report is “in the can” so to speak, blog posts are easy to write and I’m happy to take on any questions (or vendors!) in the space.

November 13, 2009 at 10:56 PM
Laura,
It must be coincidence, I just signed up for SalesForce.com yesterday, and then I found your blog. Lead Automation is a key element that I was looking for and I think a facet to business that should be more mainstream than it is.
Thanks for sharing.
September 20, 2009 at 11:04 AM
When markets change due to the changing demand of customers needing to adapt to changing environments and economies, it is rare that the bigger companies offer the next solution or even take a step in the right direction.
“The 800-pound gorillas” normally offer the proven methods that just might have become outdated.
The core of most companies is email marketing enhanced with many functions and features, but nothing innovative.
New or innovative solutions are to be found with the smaller companies.
September 17, 2009 at 8:04 AM
Your quote “Modern marketing can not scale effectively without automation” could not be more accurate, nor more succinct. At Marketo, we believe the Lead Management Automation market is barely penetrated (<5%) and your report will go a long way to helping show why companies need automation solutions (and providing some objective clarity for buyers). We look forward to your additional commentary!
September 16, 2009 at 5:48 PM
Hi, Laura. Looking forward to your final report, and appreciate the dialogue around our space.
As I’m reading your post and also thinking about the draft version of the report we reviewed at Silverpop, I’m wondering if you could explain some of your thinking around nomenclature.
Specifically, I think it would be helpful here on the blog to explain how you differentiate between marketing automation and lead management automation. I know in our space that terms get thrown around, and I know you’ve given a lot of thought to your naming conventions.
So wanted to put my two cents in for a post on this at some point.
Otherwise, great post. Thanks for driving the dialogue.
September 14, 2009 at 12:29 PM
Hi Laura, looking forward to this report. Interesting that you include Salesforce.com: it’s obviously an important software vendor for B2B marketers, but I wouldn’t necessarily call it Lead Management Automation. It’s just a database with leads: no lead scoring, email marketing or landing pages. Although it’s maybe good to point this out in one of your reports
Have you considered Treehouse Interactive for inclusion in the report? I reviewed my list of lead management automation systems and that was the main one missing.
September 12, 2009 at 9:04 AM
Im waiting with baited breath for more on this. Thanks.